Transparency
A figure in a paper has to survive the day the dataset behind it is revised. These are the rules the application keeps so that it does.
In short
- A published report never changes: later data, factor editions and software versions leave it as it was.
- Every line names its dataset, method, factor and source, and the Excel export holds every line.
- What ClinImpact adds to BAFU:2026 is set apart, and each such line says where it comes from.
- What a report could not characterise is listed by name, never summed as zero.
Contents
What comes from ClinImpact, not from BAFU#
The factor database is BAFU:2026, published by the Swiss Federal Office for the Environment. ClinImpact uses it as published: every factor is calculated from the release file exactly as BAFU released it, and no BAFU dataset is renamed or changed.
A report also contains work of our own. It is listed below so that a reader can tell the two apart, and each such line in a report says where it comes from.
- Transport to the hospital
We calculate the distance from each manufacturer to the hospital (by road, or by sea to Antwerp and then by road), through a distributor's site where one is set, and the mass shipped. The line shows the distance and how it was obtained (Methods: Transport).
This leg carries the finished product. Transport that a BAFU dataset already includes, such as a material's way to a regional storehouse, is an earlier leg and is left as it is.
From BAFU: the lorry and ship transport datasets, as published, per tonne-kilometre.
- Recycled LDPE granulate, a ClinImpact recipe
BAFU:2026 has no inventory for mechanically recycled LDPE film, so we built one after Martín-Lara et al. (2022), J Clean Prod 365:132625. Its line reads “ClinImpact recipe (BAFU:2026 inputs)” and names that source (Methods: Recipes).
From BAFU: every input of the recipe (electricity, water, chemicals, wastewater treatment), as published.
- Hypafix adhesive dressing, a ClinImpact recipe
BAFU:2026 has no such product, so ClinImpact models one roll: backing, fatty alcohol and paper as modelled, packaging, conversion energy and transport. Its line reads “ClinImpact recipe (BAFU:2026 inputs)” (Methods: Recipes).
From BAFU: every input of the recipe, as published.
- The hospital's electricity grid
Electricity is calculated with the national grid of the hospital's country, whichever grid a product's own entry named, and the line says which grid was used. A ClinImpact recipe keeps the grids its own inventory names (Methods: Room use).
From BAFU: the national low- and medium-voltage grid datasets, as published.
- Recycled material
Counted as zero under the cut-off rule of BAFU:2026, with no dataset behind it. A substitution credit appears only as a sensitivity and never enters the result (Methods: Waste).
From BAFU: the cut-off system model of BAFU:2026.
- Drugs and anaesthetic gases
Drug footprints come from published studies, which each line names. The gases are counted as emitted, with the global warming potentials of IPCC AR6 (Methods: Factors from the literature and Methods: Anaesthetic gases).
From BAFU: nothing. These factors are not taken from BAFU:2026.
A published report never changes#
Publishing a report freezes every line: the quantity, the dataset and its UUID, the method and impact category, the factor, its edition and extraction date, and the result.
Later versions of the application, later editions of the factor database and later corrections to a product leave a published version untouched. A project can be published again as a new version, and the old one stays readable with its own figures and date.
A version found to be wrong is withdrawn with its reason, and its lines stay as the record.
Every line names its source#
Each line of a report carries the dataset it was multiplied by, the method, the factor and where that factor came from (the database edition for a material, the paper for a drug).
- The Excel export holds every line with every column.
- The PDF holds the same lines grouped as the page shows them.
- The Standard report adds a document-control page with a SHA-256 fingerprint of the frozen figures, against which a copy can be checked.
Versions say whether figures are comparable#
A version number says whether figures may have changed:
- PATCH
Never changes a figure.
- MINOR
May change figures, because an emission factor or the report arithmetic changed.
- MAJOR
A break in the data model or the method.
Each release in the changelog opens with a "Figures:" line that says whether its figures are comparable with the previous release and, if not, why. A release that brings several versions at once compares with the release before it and covers them all, so a release numbered as a PATCH can say "not comparable" when it brings a MINOR.
Every report and export carries the software version, the catalogue edition and the method beside the figures.
What is not counted#
Some things lie outside every report:
- the hospital building and its capital equipment;
- staff and patient travel;
- care before and after the procedure;
- the manufacture of the reusable instrument sets that are sterilised but not listed among the products. Their reprocessing is counted, under Sterilisation.
A reusable product that is listed among the products counts its production, end of life and transport divided by its uses over its life, 400 unless recorded otherwise. Anaesthetic agents are counted as emitted, and as manufactured where a production factor is recorded.
Within a report, anything that could not be characterised is listed by name under “What is not counted”, with the reason, instead of being summed as zero.
Two ways of counting waste#
Waste can be counted in two ways:
- by weighing the bin after each procedure, with the hospital's disposal dataset and its distance to the processor;
- per product, from the mass of each component marked with a disposal dataset.
The two describe the same waste and are never added. A project counts the weighed bin when any procedure was weighed and the waste per product otherwise, and each published version records which. Where a project has both, the report shows the other figure and the difference beside the result.
The full method is in Methods: Waste.
Public links#
A published report or comparison can be shared by a link that needs no account. Such a link serves one frozen version and nothing else, and it can be revoked. Once a version is withdrawn, its link shows nothing.